The DeKalb City Council passed a resolution Monday night encouraging the use of recyclable packaging materials, but two council members argued over its effectiveness.

Seventh Ward Alderman Jeff Monroe submitted a proposal encouraging DeKalb businesses to use recyclable packaging materials.

The resolution asked local consumers to “make environmentally conscious choices in their selection of products and businesses,” according to the city council agenda.

Sixth Ward Alderman Jamie Pennington suggested altering the resolution.

“I would like to see either a ban of styrofoam in the city or … some economic incentives to private industries who choose not to use styrofoam,” Pennington said.

He suggested a tax or surcharge on the sale of plastic foam products to fund recycling programs.

Monroe disagreed. “There have been cities that have gone out and banned styrofoam. But whether DeKalb is ready to do that, I don’t know,” he said.

However, Pennington said, “Although I can’t speak for every council member, I think some would think that after passing a resolution they can say ‘we are environmentally conscious; we are aware.’

And what I am saying is the passing of this resolution does not say that. We need to follow the resolution up with action,” he said.

Monroe said, “I think Jamie has, in a reactionary sense, set off a negative reaction among fellow council members. As far as going any further on this issue, I am very hesitant to pursue it.

I think he was more interested in shooting his mouth off … than getting anything done,” Monroe said.