Comparing the films based on the novel ‘Charlie and the Chocolate Factory’
March 2, 2022
Those of us with a sweet tooth have probably dreamed of a wonderland of sweet confections. In 1971, audiences witnessed the closest thing to a sweet world of wonder in the form of the film “Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory.”
The film was directed by Mel Stuart and stars Gene Wilder as the eccentric owner of the Wonka factory. The plot is centered around a poor boy named Charlie, played by Peter Ostrum, who seeks one of five golden tickets that will grant access to a tour of the world-famous yet mysterious Wonka chocolate factory.
This musical fantasy film was an adaptation of the Roald Dahl novel of a similar name, “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.” It is filled with memorable songs and a colorful setting that brings joy to young and old viewers. The film was not a massive success upon its release, according to box office numbers and reviews from IMDB, but has garnered a following through the years. The film was an Oscar nominee for best music, scoring adaptation and original song score in 1972, according to IMDB.
Lots of younger people who know of the film are probably familiar through home video copies such as DVDs or may have even come across it through streaming services like Netflix.
Many also remember the 2005 adaptation of the novel, also titled “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory,” directed by Tim Burton. In this version, Johnny Depp plays Willy Wonka. This film has the same, if not a very similar, plot of the original 1971 film. However, it does take some liberties and has differences from the 1971 film.
The 2005 film puts a heavier emphasis on science fiction and the updated technologies of the factory. Unlike the 1971 film, it gives a deeper backstory to Willy Wonka himself and even more knowledge about the Oompa Loompas.
The music was not as memorable in the 2005 film as it was in the 1971 film with nostalgic songs and set pieces being replaced by more electronic pop and sci-fi aesthetics.
It’s debatable which film was wackier due to the antics, but it’s safe to say that both actors played a very eccentric Willy Wonka. Johnny Depp’s version of the character was slightly creepier, but this is due to the creative aesthetic of director Tim Burton.
The ending is slightly different in the 2005 version. The original ended with Charlie inheriting the chocolate factory because he was the most morally good child of the five children on the tour. In the 2005 version, Charlie initially declines the offer to inherit the factory but does help Willy Wonka reconcile with his father and realizes the value of family, eventually still allowing Charlie and his family to move into the factory together.
A new generation of viewers will be able to witness Willy Wonka for themselves with a new iteration coming in 2023 with the film “Wonka” with Timothée Chalamet playing the young chocolatier. This film is set to be a prequel to the novel and will focus on a young Willy Wonka and his adventures prior to opening the chocolate factory, according to IMDB.