Victory for UN
March 5, 1991
Now that the Gulf War appears to be ending, it is time for the American people to reflect back and do the serious work of analysis concerning this and any war.
Those who have felt criticisms should not be voiced while we are fighting need to join others in discussion for the future. I would suggest some areas where we might begin.
It is with unexpected gratitude that the allies can speak of so few casualties. This invites us to review the military strategy that helped to achieve this.
An effort was made to destroy the Iraqi infrastructure and armaments to prepare the war. It worked for the allies.
However, it may have resulted in 100,000 plus deaths of Iraqi soldiers. The disruption of the infrastructure caused untold pain and suffering for non-combatant women and children in Iraq. Is this an acceptable cost?
Alternatives were broached prior to the war. Did we truly allow sanctions time? Now that we have access to Iraq we may begin to answer that.
Would it have been possible to enter negotiations? Did we contribute to the set up of the invasion by the signals we gave Hussein before his move?
We must develop a greater understanding of the Arab world and be more consistent in our policies.
As the Muslim holy month of Ramadam begins March 18, can Christians and Jews seek to repair breeches in our relationships with Muslims caused by the war?
All three religions call Abraham their forebear and Abraham’s God as their God. Is it appropriate for the president to close every speech with “God bless America and our troops” when that same God is the God of those whom the allies were fighting.?
We need to have a better understanding of our common heritage.
During the war many people raised questions in their minds about being conscientious objectors.
It is proper to consider that position any time, but it may be more appropriate to consider that decision apart from a particular conflict. Such questioning should not now be put aside.
And finally, Bush has spoken of a New World Order in which the nations of the world work together. He has attempted to show that in the addressing of the invasion of Kuwait.
If we are going to establish such an order, we must be willing to abide by United Nations’ critiques of our actions as well. We must not speak of an American victory, but rather a UN victory.
David Schmidt
Director, Wesley Foundation