NPR analyst gets analyzed
November 10, 2010
What strung thousands of NPR listeners into debate this week was former NPR news analyst Juan Williams’ own American perspective of Muslims in today’s society.
Williams’ appearance on the “O’Reilly Factor,” which airs on Fox News, provided what some may call a “dose of reality” when he announced it makes him nervous when he sees Muslims on the plane dressed in “Muslim garb.”
Some listeners aren’t critical of the journalist for his comments.
“I’ve always enjoyed his commentary and insights at NPR,” said Allen May, general manager of broadcast news, Department of Communications.
Despite some listeners’ attitudes, however, NPR editors did not feel the same.
Williams was fired contingent upon his violation of the networks standards. Williams spoke out by saying “I was fired for telling the truth.”
There has been a fervid debate centered around the idea of whether the comment was appropriate or not.
“There’s two ways to view this situation, one is to remain objective- you can have an opinion with the heart of the issue but you also have to represent the organization you work for especially when you’re on air,” said communications instructor Floyd Sanders.
Throughout the controversy Williams remained adamant when defending the stance he took on the show.
“They take something totally out of context,” Williams said as he addressed the issue of Americans coming to terms with their prejudices.
“There was a precedent set, however I feel as though there could have been a warning first, the firing was too extreme,” Sanders said. “I have certain opinions in front of my students, but I don’t voice them all.”
Upon Williams dismissal from NPR, though, he signed a contract with Fox News for a multi-year deal. This situation has led NIU media experts to give mainstream advice.
“Journalists entering into this field need to do your homework when trying to get a job, know the company, the facts and what they’re about,” May said. “Because they’re going to ask you.”
Journalists entering into the media world were provided an example of when and when not to inject personal opinion. “We’re merely a conduit, just a source used as an avenue,” Sanders said. “There’s always room for other opinions just not yours, unless its an editorial.”