State ballots feature hot-button social issues
November 4, 2008
Massachusetts voters overwhelmingly rejected a proposal to repeal the state income tax Tuesday as ballot measures across the nation addressed a host of contentious issues ranging from gay marriage to abortion.
The Massachusetts item would have deprived the state of an estimated 40 percent of its tax revenues and, according to leading opponents, would have forced a drastic cutback of needed programs and services.
Of the 153 measures at stake nationwide, the most momentous was a proposed constitutional amendment in California that would limit marriage to heterosexual couples.
Similar measures have prevailed previously in 27 states, but none were in California’s situation — with thousands of gay couples already married in the aftermath of a state Supreme Court ruling in May.
The opposing sides together raised about $70 million, much of it from out of state, to wage their campaigns. The outcome, either way, will have a huge impact on prospects for spreading same-sex marriage to the 47 states that do not allow it.
Though Democrat Barack Obama was heavily favored to win the presidential race in California, the vote on the marriage amendment was expected to be close. A crucial question was how churchgoing black and Hispanic voters — presumably a pro-Obama constituency — would vote on the ballot measure.
According exit polls, blacks were far more likely than whites or Hispanics to support the ban. Age also was a key factor — the exit polls showed voters under 30 opposing the ban by a 2-to-1 margin, while most voters 60 and older supported the ban.
Both Obama and his Republican rival, John McCain, say they oppose same-sex marriage. But Obama, unlike McCain, also opposes the California amendment and endorses the concept of broader rights for same-sex couples.
Ban-gay-marriage amendments also were on the ballot in Florida and Arizona. Under Florida law, the measure there needed 60 percent support to be enacted — partial returns showed it very close to that threshold.
Arkansas had a measure that would prohibit unmarried couples from adopting or being foster parents. Conservatives supporting the measure say it’s aimed at same-sex couples, who are able to adopt and be foster parents in most states.
South Dakota’s ballot included an initiative that would ban abortion except in cases of rape, incest and serious health threat to the mother. A tougher law without the rape and incest exceptions was defeated in 2006; a recent poll on the new version suggested the outcome was too close to call.
If it passed, it would likely trigger a legal challenge which could lead to the U.S. Supreme Court and a reconsideration of the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling that established the right to abortion.
Colorado had a proposed amendment that would define human life as beginning at conception. It doesn’t explicitly mention abortion, but activists on both sides in the campaign view it as a direct challenge to abortion rights.
Two other measures also have drawn the interest of the rival sides in the abortion debate — a California proposition that would require parental notification for a minor’s abortion and a Michigan initiative that would loosen restrictions on stem cell research.
Initiatives in Colorado and Nebraska would ban race- and gender-based affirmative action, similar to measures previously approved in California, Michigan and Washington. The movement’s leader, California activist-businessman Ward Connerly, says the candidacies of Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and Sarah Palin prove blacks and women no longer need affirmative action.
In Washington state, voters were deciding whether to join Oregon as the only states offering terminally ill people the option of physician-assisted suicide.
Massachusetts had measures that would ban dog racing and decriminalize possession of an ounce or less of marijuana. Use of marijuana for medical purposes would become legal under a measure in Michigan.
Among the other ballot items:
—Measures inspired by unease over immigration would designate English as the official language of government proceedings in Missouri and limit teaching of students in languages other than English to no more than two years in Oregon.
—A Missouri measure would require the state to generate 15 percent of its electricity from clean energy by 2021. A California measure would require all utilities to generate 20 percent of their power from renewable energy by 2010, and 50 percent by 2025.
—Another California measure would authorize the sale of $9.95 billion in bonds to fund a high-speed rail line between Los Angeles and San Francisco. It would be the most ambitious state rail project ever.